One of the cleaner clawfoot tubs we've had in quite a while. There are no deal breaker/significant flaws on this one. The area around the drain is free or rust. There's no excessive wear under the overflow from a leaky faucet and no chips around the lip. The tub does show some surface scratches that are typical with normal use, but it still has surprisingly good luster. No rust on the bottom and the feet are all in great condition with good set screws. The only thing to knock it down a peg is there is some light pitting in the basin.